59. An outsourcing proposal lowers routine cost but concentrates a critical service in one provider. How would you evaluate it?
HardCommercial judgment
Case
Show model answer
Assess service requirements, failure consequences, provider capability, dependencies, transition, oversight, and realistic alternatives if service deteriorates. Include retained internal work and recovery needs alongside the quoted routine price.
Compare credible operating and disruption scenarios with commercial, technical, risk, and legal owners. Do not equate a service-level clause with proven resilience or assume diversification is costless; show the actual trade-off and decision conditions.
What interviewers listen for
- Include transition, oversight, and failure scenarios
- Assess real alternatives and recovery capability
- Distinguish contract promises from demonstrated resilience