39. A source offers exclusive access only if you remove a well-supported criticism. How would you advise the editor?
HardEditorial craft & verification
Case
Show model answer
Clarify the proposed condition, its timing, and any prior agreement. Assess how accepting it would affect independence, accuracy, and the audience’s understanding, while checking the criticism’s evidence and giving a fair opportunity for relevant response.
Present the trade-off to the editor rather than privately bargaining away a finding. Consider alternative reporting or declining access, and document boundaries against undisclosed control over the story.
What interviewers listen for
- Clarify the access condition and prior agreement
- Protect evidence and fair contextual treatment
- Escalate material independence trade-offs