47. Management’s explanation supports an estimate, but independent market information points the other way. How would you respond?
MediumAudit & assurance
Technical
Show model answer
Investigate the inconsistency rather than selecting the source that supports the expected result. Check dates, scope, relevance, reliability and whether either source has been altered or misunderstood.
Obtain additional evidence and reassess the estimate and associated risks with the engagement team. Document how the contradiction was resolved or what uncertainty remains; management confidence alone does not eliminate the need to evaluate contrary evidence.
What interviewers listen for
- Investigate both sources
- Seek relevant corroboration
- Record unresolved uncertainty