61. Two competent specialists give you incompatible advice on a consequential piece of work. How would you move forward?
HardSituational & STAR
Case
Show model answer
Ask which assumptions, evidence, scope, and decision criteria produce the disagreement. Determine whether the advice concerns different circumstances or a genuine unresolved trade-off rather than choosing the more confident speaker.
Obtain the appropriate decision or additional review, documenting uncertainty and consequences. Do not average incompatible recommendations into a false compromise or present your preference as a specialist conclusion beyond your competence.
What interviewers listen for
- Compare assumptions, scope, and evidence
- Distinguish factual conflict from value trade-offs
- Use appropriate authority and preserve uncertainty