33. A new customer offer attracts buyers but existing customers switch to cheaper plans to obtain similar value. How would you assess the campaign?
HardStrategy & positioning
Show model answer
Measure incremental new-customer contribution alongside downgrades, retention, support cost and changed purchase timing. Examine eligibility, customer understanding and whether the offer exposes a genuine packaging problem.
Compare the full portfolio effect with a credible counterfactual, using a holdout or phased rollout where practical. Consider revising the offer, packaging or audience rather than hiding better value from existing customers. Recommend based on sustained economics and customer trust, with explicit uncertainty.
What interviewers listen for
- Portfolio-level economics
- Eligibility and packaging effects
- Credible counterfactual
- Sustained customer value