60. An environmental indicator improves after an intervention. Why might a before-and-after comparison alone be insufficient?
HardLife & environmental research
Technical
Show model answer
Other time-varying influences, natural fluctuations or measurement changes could explain some or all of the difference. The comparison does not reveal what would have happened without the intervention.
Consider suitable comparison sites, repeated periods and design-specific analysis, while checking whether their assumptions are credible. Explain remaining uncertainty and avoid treating the sequence of intervention then improvement as complete evidence of causation.
What interviewers listen for
- Consider the missing counterfactual
- Assess alternative time effects
- Use suitable comparison evidence