99. How would you teach students to compare two credible sources that disagree?
MediumTeaching practice
Technical
Show model answer
I would identify what each source actually claims, its evidence, purpose and relevant expertise. Credibility is not a guarantee of agreement, and different questions, definitions or methods can explain apparently conflicting conclusions without implying dishonesty.
I would model comparison and ask learners to justify a bounded judgment with uncertainty. The goal is reasoned evaluation, not selecting the source that agrees with a preference or counting citations as votes for truth.
What interviewers listen for
- Identify claims and evidence
- Compare methods and scope
- Justify a bounded conclusion