54. A customer appears unprofitable after a large allocation of shared overhead. Should the client immediately stop serving them?
MediumCommercial judgment
Case
Show model answer
Separate attributable revenue and costs from allocated expenses that would remain, and assess capacity, contractual obligations, relationship effects, and realistic alternatives. The reported loss may not equal the financial improvement from ending the relationship.
Compare incremental scenarios with the relevant commercial and finance owners. Do not assume the customer should stay either; identify whether repricing, changed service, or exit improves total outcomes under supported assumptions.
What interviewers listen for
- Separate allocated reporting from avoidable economics
- Include capacity and relationship consequences
- Compare evidence-supported commercial alternatives